Paid advertisement
Smart Money People Logo
Newsletter
Share this page

Newcastle Building Society reviews

Newcastle Building Society Logo
Rated Average • 3.09/5

Newcastle Building Society reviews

Verified business Last reviewed within 7 days

Review summary

People rate this company as Average based on 30 product reviews

Average score of 3.09/5
5 star
53%
4 star
17%
3 star
3%
2 star
7%
1 star
20%
Reviews for Newcastle Building Society have trended negatively over the past 90 days

Latest positive rating

5.00/5

Excellent Support

I am currently in the process of porting my mortgage and have been working with an excellent mortgage advisor who has shown extraordinary patience. She... I am currently in the process of porting my mortgage and have been working with an excellent mortgage advisor who has shown extraordinary patience. She has taken the time to listen and explain everything in a way that I could easily understand. Even when issues arose during the process, she consistently found solutions and guided me through each step, offering unwavering support throughout. Read more Read less

Latest negative rating

1.00/5

AVOID!!AVOID!!

AVOID NEWCASTLE BUILDING SOCIETY\! INCOMPETENT, MISLEADING AND COMPLETELY UNPROFESSIONAL I cannot stress enough how appalling my experience with Newcastle Building Society has been If you’re... AVOID NEWCASTLE BUILDING SOCIETY\! INCOMPETENT, MISLEADING AND COMPLETELY UNPROFESSIONAL I cannot stress enough how appalling my experience with Newcastle Building Society has been If you’re considering using them for a mortgage, I would strongly recommend looking elsewhere I have been trying to arrange what should be a relatively straightforward transfer of an existing mortgage into my sole name. Instead, I have been met with an unbelievable level of incompetence, contradictory information, poor communication and repeated mistakes I have been told my application could proceed, then told it couldn’t I have had TWO mortgage advisor appointments arranged, only to subsequently discover they had been booked in error because my application hadn’t actually been approved Even more astonishingly, their Mortgage Advice Coordinator requested financial documents, acknowledged receiving them, and then subsequently informed me they were the wrong documents. Why wasn’t this identified immediately? Surely someone working in mortgage applications should understand what documentation is required It took me repeatedly chasing and speaking to another member of staff to finally establish what was actually needed Nobody seems to know what they’re doing, nobody takes ownership, and the customer is left to deal with the consequences The lack of transparency is staggering. You are told one thing one day and something completely different the next. Appointments are booked incorrectly, information is poorly communicated, and the entire process feels completely disorganised What makes this particularly serious is that these aren’t minor inconveniences. Mortgages involve people’s homes, finances and legal commitments. In my case, their handling of this application is now delaying significant legal and business arrangements, creating enormous stress and exposing me to potential financial losses. To make matters worse, when I asked about moving to another lender because I had lost confidence in their service, I was informed I could face an early repayment charge. So after all the mistakes and delays, I could potentially face a substantial penalty simply for wanting to take my mortgage elsewhere I have now raised formal complaints and instructed my solicitors about the situatio. I am also considering pursuing recovery of any financial losses resulting from their handling of my application My confidence in Newcastle Building Society has been completely destroyed An apology means very little when the same mistakes keep happening and nobody seems capable of providing accurate information or a clear way forward I would expect far better from a regulated financial institution dealing with something as important as people’s homes My advice? STAY WELL CLEAR. Save yourself the stress, frustration and uncertainty and find a mortgage provider that actually knows what it’s doing. An absolutely disgraceful experience, and one I wouldn’t wish on anyone. Read more Read less

About Newcastle Building Society

Newcastle Building Society was formed in 1980 as a result of a merger between the Grainger (founded 1861) and Newcastle Permanent Building Societies (founded 1863).

As a mutual organisation, the Society reinvests profits for the benefit of members as it doesn’t have any shareholders to pay. It’s the region’s largest building society with 31 branches stretching across the North East, Cumbria and North Yorkshire.

Newcastle Building Society provide a range of products across mortgages and savings.

Newcastle Building Society at a glance

Reviews for Newcastle Building Society

Showing 11 of 30 company reviews • Last reviewed within 7 days

AVOID!!AVOID!!

Fixed Rate Mortgage • 17th November 2026

AVOID NEWCASTLE BUILDING SOCIETY\! INCOMPETENT, MISLEADING AND COMPLETELY UNPROFESSIONAL I cannot stress enough how appalling my experience with Newcastle Building Society has been If you’re... AVOID NEWCASTLE BUILDING SOCIETY\! INCOMPETENT, MISLEADING AND COMPLETELY UNPROFESSIONAL I cannot stress enough how appalling my experience with Newcastle Building Society has been If you’re considering using them for a mortgage, I would strongly recommend looking elsewhere I have been trying to arrange what should be a relatively straightforward transfer of an existing mortgage into my sole name. Instead, I have been met with an unbelievable level of incompetence, contradictory information, poor communication and repeated mistakes I have been told my application could proceed, then told it couldn’t I have had TWO mortgage advisor appointments arranged, only to subsequently discover they had been booked in error because my application hadn’t actually been approved Even more astonishingly, their Mortgage Advice Coordinator requested financial documents, acknowledged receiving them, and then subsequently informed me they were the wrong documents. Why wasn’t this identified immediately? Surely someone working in mortgage applications should understand what documentation is required It took me repeatedly chasing and speaking to another member of staff to finally establish what was actually needed Nobody seems to know what they’re doing, nobody takes ownership, and the customer is left to deal with the consequences The lack of transparency is staggering. You are told one thing one day and something completely different the next. Appointments are booked incorrectly, information is poorly communicated, and the entire process feels completely disorganised What makes this particularly serious is that these aren’t minor inconveniences. Mortgages involve people’s homes, finances and legal commitments. In my case, their handling of this application is now delaying significant legal and business arrangements, creating enormous stress and exposing me to potential financial losses. To make matters worse, when I asked about moving to another lender because I had lost confidence in their service, I was informed I could face an early repayment charge. So after all the mistakes and delays, I could potentially face a substantial penalty simply for wanting to take my mortgage elsewhere I have now raised formal complaints and instructed my solicitors about the situatio. I am also considering pursuing recovery of any financial losses resulting from their handling of my application My confidence in Newcastle Building Society has been completely destroyed An apology means very little when the same mistakes keep happening and nobody seems capable of providing accurate information or a clear way forward I would expect far better from a regulated financial institution dealing with something as important as people’s homes My advice? STAY WELL CLEAR. Save yourself the stress, frustration and uncertainty and find a mortgage provider that actually knows what it’s doing. An absolutely disgraceful experience, and one I wouldn’t wish on anyone. Read more Read less

Rated Terrible • 1.00/5
Read more product reviews

Excellent Support

Fixed Rate Mortgage • 9th April 2026

I am currently in the process of porting my mortgage and have been working with an excellent mortgage advisor who has shown extraordinary patience. She... I am currently in the process of porting my mortgage and have been working with an excellent mortgage advisor who has shown extraordinary patience. She has taken the time to listen and explain everything in a way that I could easily understand. Even when issues arose during the process, she consistently found solutions and guided me through each step, offering unwavering support throughout. Read more Read less

Rated Excellent • 5.00/5
Read more product reviews
  • 5.00/5

    TOONARMY

    Do a great job for our local hero and legend wot sir Bobby Robson

  • 5.00/5

    5 out of 5 stars...from me

    Ray Sisterson 49 reviews GB Rated 5 out of 5 stars 2nd to none I have been helped today i can not tell you how... Ray Sisterson 49 reviews GB Rated 5 out of 5 stars 2nd to none I have been helped today i can not tell you how far this person went to see me right today 100 % Fantastic could not ask for any better so thank you Laura Moorhead 5* from me Date of experience: 15 April 2025 Read more Read less

  • 5.00/5

    Had a mortgage prodcuct transfer, I was offered bett...

    Had a mortgage prodcuct transfer, I was offered better rates with Newcastle as my current provider, that any other provider could offer

  • 2.00/5

    No compassion or understanding for members

    I have a lot of money in a 5 year bond taken out when interest rates were very low. I politely asked if I could... I have a lot of money in a 5 year bond taken out when interest rates were very low. I politely asked if I could renegotiate the interest rate by a couple of percentage points but was told no. Whilst I understand that I had a contract I would have liked them to demonstrate some compassion, especially in view of how much their CEO and others are earning. Read more Read less

  • 5.00/5

    Easy and simple

    No issues, went through a third party but will probably go to NCBS direct next time as so easy.

  • 5.00/5

    Very easy to use and good interest

    Simple, straightforward and no issues.

    {"display":"Matt Bowles","full_name":"Matt Bowles","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Lifetime ISA
    Matt Bowles 28th February 2023
  • 5.00/5

    Easy to open and great account

    The online journey was simple and the account will help save for a house deposit

    {"display":"Ben","full_name":"Ben","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Lifetime ISA
    Ben 15th January 2022
  • 5.00/5

    Good rate and quick product transfer

    I stayed with Newcastle Building Society after 2 years into my mortgage. They offered very good rate and the process was really simple to switch.

  • 1.00/5

    Wasting people's time

    After offering us £20,000 more than we wanted on a mortgage principal certificate we decided to go with them both of us have good jobs... After offering us £20,000 more than we wanted on a mortgage principal certificate we decided to go with them both of us have good jobs and an excellent credit rating without a reason decided to decline the mortgage why offer a mortgage in principle if you take it away there slogan is to look after the people of the North East what a load of rubbish Read more Read less

    Products from Newcastle Building Society

    Showing products offered by Newcastle Building Society

    We are Smart Money People

    Join 2 million active users who make better financial decisions with the power of reviews.

    Create an account

    Protecting trust by verifying companies and reviewers

    The only site that specialises in financial services

    Providing everyday people with a voice