Paid advertisement
Smart Money People Logo
Newsletter

NFU Mutual: Car insurance reviews

3.75
Based on 55 reviews, last reviewed 10th Nov 2026
500% increase in 5 star reviews
in the past 90 days
200% increase in 1 star reviews
in the past 90 days
See only 5 star reviews
75%
See only 4 star reviews
7%
See only 3 star reviews
7%
2 star
See only 2 star reviews
0%
See only 1 star reviews
11%

Latest highest rating:

5

Excellent customer service... Just before Christmas they were notified of accident and curtesy car provided the same day. Claim handled very efficiently. Reviewed on: 13th October 2026
Marionpitcher@sky.com's avatar
[email protected]

Latest lowest rating:

1

NFU simply gathers competitors pricing data! NFU simply engages in a price data gathering on it's competitors when potential customers make a car insurance price enquiry, rather than providing an... Read more Reviewed on: 10th November 2026
RD's avatar
RD

About this product

NFU Mutual provide comprehensive insurance policies for most types of vehicles - from cars to motorcycles, motorhomes to vans.

Each type of vehicle has its own type of policy to help customers find the right level of cover. Some policies also include extras you may expect to pay for from other insurers.

NFU Mutual motor insurance reviews help you find out what it’s like to be a customer. If you’ve used NFU Mutual before, you can also leave a review and share your experience.

Review NFU Mutual: Car insurance now

Help others make smarter decisions by sharing your own experience. Write a review

NFU Mutual Car insurance reviews (55)

NFU simply gathers competitors pricing data!

1
NFU simply engages in a price data gathering on it's competitors when potential customers make a car insurance price enquiry, rather than providing an actual car insurance quote! That's really a dishonest way to behave. This year and last year NFU mutual won't allow an enquiry without a competitor's renewal quote being provided and then refusing to show it's own price stating NFU thinks it would be 'uncompetitive'. But that's for the customer to decide based on his/her assessment of the relative pro's and cons of different companies/policies and NFU have no way of knowing that. In practice customers, such as I, often do not insure with the cheapest company and often pay considerably more for a policy/company they consider to be better. NFU, like other insurance companies, should always provide a price (if they are willing to insure) and let customers decide, rather than using this exercise to manipulate an unfair advantage over it's competitors. Reviewed on: 10th November 2026

Excellent customer service...

5
Just before Christmas they were notified of accident and curtesy car provided the same day. Claim handled very efficiently. Reviewed on: 13th October 2026

Outstanding all - rounder

5
Excellent Customer Service. Good loyalty discount upon renewal date. Trustworthy, caring organisation, supporting the agriculture industry. ***** HIGHLY RECCOMMENDED ***** Reviewed on: 13th October 2026

CANCELLED ALL my Policies

1
I have CANCELLED ALL my insurance… I have CANCELLED ALL my insurance policies with NFU. They expected me to drive with a broken car windscreen 22+ miles, 50 mins, to get it repaired, no repair available in my drive even though car windscreen covered my insurance. I am nearly 80. Also their policies are v v expensive. Date of breakage sometime in July I think, torn up all their 3 Policies. Reviewed on: 8th October 2026

Very good at sorting out claims though quite expensive

5
Very good at sorting out claims though quite expensive Reviewed on: 2nd September 2026

Customer service second to none.

5
Accident referred to NFU Mutual who dealt with the claim with no hassle. Excellent customer service. Reviewed on: 20th August 2026

Easy and helpful to deal with

5
Always pleasant and helpful to deal with, quick and efficient. And a pleasure to be rewarded for loyalty as always easier to stick with the same provider than start doing research and switch. When I added a 3rd driver to my policy, it brought my premium down which was an added nice surprise. Reviewed on: 20th August 2026

Just got car renewal in the post.

3
Just got car renewal in the post. The quotation was less than last year which is a first in my previous renewals. Renewal figure normally quite a lot higher Reviewed on: 16th April 2026

Great people good company they are very helpful and...

5
Great people good company they are very helpful and give you options to choose from to simultaneously your needs Reviewed on: 6th September 2025

customer service

5
I renewed my insurance this year over the phone and the process was easy Reviewed on: 15th October 2024

Do you have a different NFU Mutual product?

Share your experiences with products to help others make smarter financial decisions and learn more about different products available. Write a review
Are you a business? Get insights, reply to reviews, invite customers and understand their needs

Want to see more from NFU Mutual?

  • Home insurance

    from NFU Mutual 4.62 from 73 reviews
    NFU Mutual
  • Pet Insurance

    from NFU Mutual 4.29 from 8 reviews
    NFU Mutual
  • Business Insurance

    from NFU Mutual 4.12 from 5 reviews
    NFU Mutual
    View all products