Write a review

Carrot Insurance: Car Insurance reviews

Name: Car Insurance
Rating: 1.54 (46 reviews)

View other Carrot Insurance products

1.38

Based on 46 reviews, last reviewed 19th Mar 2024

No new 5 star reviews

in the past 90 days

No new 1 star reviews

in the past 90 days

11%

74%

Latest highest rating:

4

great low price insurance as a student this seems to be a great insurance company at very reasonable prices Reviewed on: 24th August 2020

Latest lowest rating:

1

Further update from this absolute joke of a company. Further update from this absolute joke of a company. Evidently somebody behind a computer screen 400 miles away knows a road better than someone with ... Read more Reviewed on: 19th March 2024

Read all reviews See your review

About this product

Car insurance premiums can become costly depending on your driving history among other factors. Telematics policies are designed to lower the cost of your premium by tracking aspects of your driving, but how well do they actually shape up? We collect Carrot car insurance reviews to help you make an informed decision about your next provider.

Carrot Insurance was launched in 2012, with the goal of encouraging safer driving with the use of rewards. By installing a telematics box into your vehicle, Carrot can monitor factors like speed and reckless behaviour in order to score your driving. For those scoring higher, weekly rewards are available to claim.

If you’re looking to be rewarded for your safe driving, read our Carrot Insurance car insurance reviews. Policies such as this are ideal for learners, new drivers and even more experienced drivers. If this sounds like you, read our reviews today. Find out if the rewards provided are of value, and how accurate policyholders believe the telematics are at scoring their driving.

Have you had a policy with Carrot Insurance? Whether good or bad, share your experience with our Smart Money People community. How did you find the telematics included with this policy? Did you feel like Carrot scored your driving fairly? Did you redeem many rewards, and were they of value to you? Did you have to make a claim, and if so, how well was it handled? Leave an honest Carrot car insurance review today. Together, we can help people like you make better decisions.

Carrot Insurance Car Insurance reviews (46)

Review of the Carrot Insurance, Car Insurance:

student/new driver insurance

this seems to be a great insurance provider for new or student drivers at a reasonable price Reviewed on: 24th August 2020

Stay Clear

STAY CLEAR! whole host of problems, the app is very temperamental and doesn’t always work and the response when trying to sort it usually consisted of “leave the app open” which drained battery and used miles up. A new problem with it arose every other week. Also just had my renewal with a email stating “ Please be aware, Carrot WILL NOT automatically renew this policy.” followed by an email 2 weeks later stating my policy had been renewed with a credit agreement set up with a credit broker! Even after messaging them stating I wanted to NOT renew I received an email later that day stating a direct debit set up that had been SIGNED..... without telling me mind. I know it’s a touch cheaper but PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do not use this company, pay the extra £5/£10 a month and go with the next cheapest, you’ll regret it if you don’t. Never written a review for anything in my life but felt compelled to do so today! Reviewed on: 2nd September 2020

great low price insurance

as a student this seems to be a great insurance company at very reasonable prices Reviewed on: 24th August 2020

The WORST

Please avoid this company. Even if getting an app sunds easier than having a black box installed, it is not worth it. Unfortunately it's not possible to give zero stars. Instead of writing a huge rant (because I've just had to write one out on email to complain to them), I will summarise. 1. Hidden charges everywhere you look. I got charged £30 because I put one single number wrong on a form once. £30! I wasn't warned there would be a charge if there were any mistakes. Why did I even need to fill in the form if they had access to the information and they were going to charge me anyway? Probably so I would make a mistake and they could make money. 2. I also got charged a ridiculous amount of money to cancel my policy (which I was not warned would be the case when I cancelled) and they straight up refused to email me with a bill. Instead I just got a text telling me I owed them money. 3. You can only contact them through a live chat, which is only open till 6pm. Not great if you work 9-5 as most people do. They're also very slow at replying and not particularly helpful when they do reply. 4. The Wingman does not work and they will threaten to cancel your insurance because of this! My wingman broke so many times and when I would try to get a new one, I would have to go out of my way on the live chat to find out that I was not being sent a new one and I would have to find some other way to fix it. Did I mention they'll threaten to cancel your insurance if it doesn't work. Overall, this company turned me into a Karen - the sort of person who wants to shout at innocent employees who are just trying to do their job. But seriously, don't waste your money, find a more reputable service provider. Reviewed on: 27th November 2019

Do NOT bother

Do not waste your time buying insurance from this incredibly incompetent company. I saved a couple hundred quid by going with carrot but the amount of wasted time effort energy calls messaging I’ve had to put in because THEIR app doesn’t work at all is a joke and worth so much more than a bit of cash. Pay more to stop yourself going grey - 10000% worst excuse of a company I’ve ever had to deal with (does it even count as dealing with if they ignore you) Reviewed on: 7th June 2019

Do not insure with Carrot - The most unprofessional insurance company in the world

Beware: This company is scamming people. They offer low insurance policies then hit you with cancellation notices unless you pay further premiums. My son has had two cancellation notices and two premium increases of £100 and £200 for no good reason. We tried calling and were on hold for 60 minutes before we gave up. Absolutely impossible to talk to anyone - they offer communication through twitter facebook but will not answer emails. Cancellation fees are 35% of the total policy. This needs to be taken further - I would have given zero rating but the review process only allows you to progress with at least one star - very angry and frustrated. Reviewed on: 29th April 2019

Confusing and frustrating

Positives - Great price for the insurance cover. Bloke arrived on time to fit the black box. Friendly staff on the phone. Negatives - takes ages to get through to anyone either using phone or live chat. the Black box is very confusing - it can give you 10/10 for a journey, then a minus score for exactly the same journey a few hours later. You never know what score you are going to be given by the Black Box and it becomes very frustrating to have driven perfectly only to see a negative score appear on your system. It seems as though the Black box pulls figures out of thin air or makes them up to give you a low score. You can be threatened with cancellation if you have a negative score for a week, but be offered to sit a test with 'driving doctor' and if you pass, you get the negative week removed from your Record. I received an email from driving doctor telling me I passed, but Carrot emailed me and told me I had failed. Decided to cut my losses and cancel my policy as it was causing too much confusion and aggravation rather than helping me to become a better driver, which was the whole point of the policy. The whole thing prevented me from enjoying having my first car. Reviewed on: 13th April 2019

PLEASE DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY !!!!

We are 4 months into this policy and we are counting the days until it comes to an end. It was the cheapest BUT its a very true saying you get what you pay for. The black box literally makes things up as it goes along. Yesterday my daughter used the car to drive from home to college, 2.4 miles, from college to the gym 4 miles and from the gym home. The useage score out of 10 is 0 and - 0.2 .... 3 journeys, made during day ... not after 11pm or before 6am ( which they don't like despite having "no curfew" ) They will mark you down for speed on a motorway as anything over 50 mph they don't like either, and don't even get me started on smoothness! please, I wish I had read the reviews before parting with our money. I hope to goodness we don't have to claim with them Reviewed on: 5th April 2019

USELESS!!!!

If I could give Zero stars then I would’ve but they were awful, I wouldn’t recommend them at all and would advise you go elsewhere. I spent so long on hold every time I called, I was told so many different things, one of the people I spoke to made me out to be a liar, the RS company contacted me daily before my policy even started, conned out of £269 for less than a month of insurance. USELESS!!!! Reviewed on: 5th March 2019

Terrible! Worst company ever

They rely on an orange box rigged to an app on the phone. You leave it open as instructed and get data readings so you think all is fine. Then you get a letter cancelling the policy as you’ve had the app turned off WHEN YOU HAVE NOT! Seriously bad to get through to, when you do eventually get to speak to someone they basically just call you a liar! Hide behind the misguided app readings and refuse to accept that it is flawed and faulty! Costly experience leaving a 20 year Old without insurance for no valid reason (my son). In 30 years of personal driving I have never come across such a shocking insurance company or been made to feel so much like a criminal like this shower made me and my son feel like Reviewed on: 31st January 2019

AVOID AT ALL COSTS

I wouldn’t never ever waste my time giving a company a bad review online but I am literally making sure I stop as many people as possible taking car insurance out with this company, even had advisors on the phone saying I am not a bad driver but they are still going to cancel my policy and charge me for half the yearly amount of my insurance. I have only had the insurance for 3 weeks and even paid 160 pound deposit which I am not getting back from them, they think it’s ok penalise drivers for driving 31mph in 30 zone or if your need brake sharply at any point when your driving which can happen because of hazards or other drivers etc, I have been driving since I was 18 and I am now 25 never heard anything like it from a car insurance company in my life even Mr Bean would have his policy cancelled by this joke of a company, so unless you want to speak to advisors who don’t have a clue what they are talking about or tell you can’t be over the speed limit at any point or can’t brake sharply because your policy will be cancelled then this is the car insurance for you if not avoid at all costs and it will save you time, money and hassle. So in a nutshell THIS CAR INSURANCE IS FUCKING SHIT DONT GET CAR INSURANCE FROM THEM Reviewed on: 19th December 2018

Are you a business? Get insights, reply to reviews, invite customers and understand their needs

Join Smart Money People

Keep up to date on ratings of your favourite businesses. Find out about our awards and write new reviews with ease

Create an account

News, guides and insight from our team

View resource hub