SG's community profile page - Smart Money People

Write a review

Go to business site

Viewing profile for,

SG

Total reviews written

Helpful marks given to their reviews

Times reviews seen

All reviews (1)

Review of the Lemonade, Home insurance:

View on product page

I’m leaving Lemonade because of my claims experience...

I’m leaving Lemonade because of my claims experience with Judith. My water damage claim was ultimately approved, but only after a stressful and unnecessarily adversarial process. From the start, Lemonade required evidence of the source of the leak, including a plumber/expert report. But when I followed that instruction, Judith repeatedly refused to confirm cover for the plumber/inspection costs and effectively created a catch-22: I needed evidence to proceed, but Lemonade would not recognise the reasonable cost of obtaining that evidence. Before the independent plumber’s report was available, Judith also wrote that she would temporarily close my claim because she had not heard from me, even though I was waiting for the very report Lemonade had requested. Once the report confirmed that the leak came from the upstairs unit and that my floor was damaged, Lemonade eventually approved the claim for the floor, while still refusing the plumber costs. What bothered me most was the contrast in tone. The emails were full of friendly emojis, “lovely day” language, and review requests, but when it came to the actual claim, the handling felt rigid, premature, and dismissive. Insurance is only useful when something goes wrong. In my case, the experience made me feel I had to argue basic policy and legal points myself just to get the claim assessed properly. Lemonade markets itself as simple, fair, and customer-friendly. My experience with Judith was the opposite. That is why I am leaving Lemonade. Reviewed on: 5th May 2026

We are helping 1000s to make smarter financial decisions

We use the power of consumer reviews to help increase trust and transparency in financial services and to deliver industry leading insight and events.