Anonymous's community profile page

Write a review

Go to business site

Viewing profile for,

Anonymous

Total reviews written

Helpful marks given to their reviews

Times reviews seen

All reviews (1)

Review of the Marshmallow, Car insurance:

View on product page

Very disappointing and stressful experience overall

Very disappointing and stressful experience overall. I paid a very high monthly premium for what was presented as comprehensive insurance with courtesy car cover, but after a non-fault accident I discovered that the policy was practically unusable in my situation. My vehicle was valued at around £900 while the excess was £1,000, meaning there was effectively no financially viable route through my own insurer. After reporting the accident to Marshmallow during the early hours of 20/12/2025, I only received an automated acknowledgement. Within roughly 48 hours I was already being contacted by Winn Solicitors and associated third parties, with no meaningful explanation that I was being placed into a separate credit hire/legal arrangement with potentially significant financial implications. The entire process appeared to be part of the normal Marshmallow claims journey. Despite paying for courtesy car cover, I was not provided with what most customers would reasonably expect from a standard insurer replacement vehicle process. Instead, I ended up in a complex and expensive credit hire structure which was never clearly explained upfront. Communication throughout the claim was slow, fragmented, and often handled by automated systems. During a period of financial hardship I repeatedly tried to get support and guidance, but meaningful human assistance was delayed. Marshmallow later admitted in their final complaint response that this should not have happened. I also actively tried to reduce costs myself by requesting a smaller and more fuel-efficient replacement vehicle, but this was not accommodated. To be fair, the individual customer service agents were polite and professional. My criticism is directed at the overall system, transparency, and real-world handling of claims. Marshmallow’s final response to my complaint mostly repeated policy wording while ignoring the practical realities and evidence I provided. The matter is now proceeding to the Financial Ombudsman Service with further supporting evidence. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this insurer. Reviewed on: 8th May 2026

We are helping 1000s to make smarter financial decisions

We use the power of consumer reviews to help increase trust and transparency in financial services and to deliver industry leading insight and events.