Paid advertisement
Smart Money People Logo

Voting in the Consumer credit awards 2026 is open - Vote here

Share this page

Monmouthshire Building Society reviews

Monmouthshire Building Society Logo
Rated Excellent 4.79/5

Monmouthshire Building Society reviews

Verified business Last reviewed within 7 days Customer Satisfaction Champion Consumer Guardian
  • Award winning organisation
    Award winning organisation
  • Positioned as being a socially responsible organisation
    Positioned as being a socially responsible organisation
  • Has branches you can visit in-person
    Has branches you can visit in-person
  • Manage your account or policy via an app or website
    Manage your account or policy via an app or website

Review summary

People rate this company as Excellent based on 3,256 product reviews

Average score of 4.79/5
5 star
91%
4 star
8%
3 star
0%
2 star
0%
1 star
1%
Reviews for Monmouthshire Building Society have trended positively over the past 90 days

Monmouthshire Building Society shines with its friendly, helpful staff and the comfort of local branches where you can get face-to-face advice. People really appreciate the personal touch and the ease of dealing with knowledgeable teams in Savings and Mortgages. However, the app and online services frustrate many, with slow transactions and tricky login issues, while some mortgage experiences have been less than smooth.

Positive themes

  • Monmouthshire Building Society Savings staff are friendly, helpful, and make visits a pleasure.
  • Having local branches for face-to-face service is a huge plus for Monmouthshire Savings.
  • Monmouthshire Mortgages offer professional and friendly service with clear explanations.

Negative themes

  • The Monmouthshire app is frustratingly unreliable and slow for Savings customers.
  • Mortgage service has been poor for some with slow responses and unhelpful communication.
  • Some find Monmouthshire Savings outdated and difficult to use compared to modern banks.
Summarised by AI
Was this helpful?

About Monmouthshire Building Society

Monmouthshire Building Society was founded in 1869 and is based in Newport, Wales.

As a mutual organisation, the Society reinvests profits for the benefit of members because it doesn’t have any shareholders to pay.

Monmouthshire Building Society provide a range of products across mortgages and savings.

Monmouthshire Building Society at a glance

Contact details

Website
Visit provider website
Phone
01633 844 340
Social media

Reviews for Monmouthshire Building Society

Showing 11 of 3256 company reviews Last reviewed within 7 days

Anita Morgan was excellent and very helpful

Mortgages 2nd June 2026

Anita Morgan who patiently, carefully ad thoroughly talked me through changing my mortgage was very efficient and, equally as important, did so with friendliness humour... Anita Morgan who patiently, carefully ad thoroughly talked me through changing my mortgage was very efficient and, equally as important, did so with friendliness humour and consideration for MY best choice and to provide what was best for ME Read more Read less

Rated Excellent 5.00/5
Read more product reviews
Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review following your mortgage appointment. We're so pleased to hear your positive review for Anita. We'll pass on your feedback.
2nd June 2026
Monmouthshire Building Society

Trying to set up my savings account pin its not...

Savings 1st June 2026

Trying to set up my savings account pin its not easy

Rated Average 3.00/5
Read more product reviews
Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We’re sorry to hear that you are having trouble whilst trying to set up your savings account pin. We would like to help you with this. Could you please contact our Savings and Customer Contact team on 01633 844340, where a member of the team will be happy to support you with this issue. Our contact centre is open Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday 9am-5pm and Wednesday 10am-5pm.
2nd June 2026
Monmouthshire Building Society
  • 5.00/5

    Good Savins Information

    Good friendly and knowledgeable service.

    {"display":"John E","full_name":"John E","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Savings
    John E 30th May 2026
  • 5.00/5

    Time well spent

    Most helpful and good advice. Rationisaled numero accounts .

    {"display":"R m","full_name":"R m","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Savings
    R m 29th May 2026
  • 1.00/5

    The Issue 8 Regular Saver account has been the most...

    The Issue 8 Regular Saver account has been the most difficult account I have EVER tried to open; despite being a past, satisfied, MBS customer... The Issue 8 Regular Saver account has been the most difficult account I have EVER tried to open; despite being a past, satisfied, MBS customer and still having a MBS on-line account. Before applying I checked and my account was still 'open'. I used my Web ID, password and memorable data to confirm. I assumed that I could open the new account within my on-line account. Wrong! Had to be opened in the App - that being the problem. After trying to use the App as an existing customer, and then as a new customer, I telephoned Customer Services several times. The App is a nightmare, requiring me to input a 6 digit code, a pin number, verification code, going through a 2 factor authorisation....I did eventually receive a NEW ID and a letter giving me an account number. I tried BOTH my, now, Web IDs, existing password and memorable data to open my accounts. In both cases, as an existing customer and as a new customer, I entered my personal details, bank details, communications preferences, acknowledged etc etc and when I submitted I was told that my attempt FAILED, and on more than 1 attempt in each case! After speaking to Customer Services I was then told that log-in details for on-line accounts and app-accessed accounts are different. I now appear to have 2 accounts that I cannot access. I have now removed the App from my phone. Read more Read less

    {"display":"Adoniram","full_name":"Adoniram","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Savings
    Adoniram 27th May 2026
  • 5.00/5

    Had a brilliant experience with Anita and the other...

    Had a brilliant experience with Anita and the other lady I spoke with on the phone - thank you both so much! You made my... Had a brilliant experience with Anita and the other lady I spoke with on the phone - thank you both so much! You made my remortgage a lot less stressful than I thought it was going to be! All my questions asked and future help offered for when we look to take our money from our equity. The only feedback I would give is that I tried to call multiple times across a few days and was unable to get through. I left a voicemail in the end and requested a callback which I was advised would be within 48 hours. I received the call back the next day but missed due to work commitments and there was no VM left and no second attempt at a call back. This resulted in me calling again to confirm it was MBS who had called me and requesting another call back and then also emailing Anita, who I had previously had a meeting with for some borrowing advice. A bit of a frustrating process but I understand you are very busy and I’m grateful for Anita and the other lady for contacting me and getting my remortgage sorted quickly! Read more Read less

    {"display":"Ellie H","full_name":"Ellie H","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Mortgages
    Ellie H 21st May 2026
  • 5.00/5

    My mortgage advisor Anita was so helpful and explain...

    My mortgage advisor Anita was so helpful and explained everything in detail so I fully understood what I was taking on and more importantly what... My mortgage advisor Anita was so helpful and explained everything in detail so I fully understood what I was taking on and more importantly what I can afford. I had full confidence in her which helped the process run smoothly. All of my paperwork came through promptly and Anita communication was second to non Read more Read less

    {"display":"CW","full_name":"CW","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Mortgages
    CW 21st May 2026
  • 2.00/5

    force password resets, terrible app & customer service

    So they reset your password for your bank / savings account every so often. Which is for security which is actually doing more bad than... So they reset your password for your bank / savings account every so often. Which is for security which is actually doing more bad than good. It shows people choose easier passwords to remember if they keep having to change passwords. However when you change a password, you need to provide unique ID codes which are from your original paperwork, as well as when you have your credentials reset / blocked for security so you have to update and add new ones every month, you have to provide the normal stuff like name, email etc however requiring multiple unique IDs. Account number (whoch you cant access without logging in so catch 22) and if you leave the app to go to your emails, it wipes all data fields and sends you back to the beginning. Then once you do enter the correct information. It said it wasnt valid which okay, theres a chance thats true even though i copied and pasted the exact info and ID numbers, but then locks you out from attempting anything within the app and they have bad customer service access with no online chat. It doesnt need to be 24 hour, but even an email address to contact would be good but they are all no reply addresses. Only way is to call them between office hours. Which surprise surprise is mon-fri, 9-5pm so, as someone who works those hours but cant take a phone call apart from on a lunch break but guess what, everyone else is calling on their lunch break too. Just it seems they have set everything up to be so difficult that they WANT you to lose access to your savings account. Because if its paying interest annually, you dont need to keep checking in on it, so they reset your details a few months later, make the app difficult to try to recover your own money and then make it difficult to contact them. Disappointing service all round. Read more Read less

    {"display":"R N","full_name":"R N","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Savings
    R N 15th May 2026
  • 5.00/5

    47 years of excellent service from Monmouthshire BS

    Excellent service from a very helpful and knowledgeable employee named Mussarat. My late husband and I, although saving with many financial institutions, struggled to obtain... Excellent service from a very helpful and knowledgeable employee named Mussarat. My late husband and I, although saving with many financial institutions, struggled to obtain a mortgage prior to our wedding in 1979 but the Monmouthshire BS were extremely helpful and we have always stayed loyal to them. I would highly recommend them. Read more Read less

    {"display":"Anonymous","full_name":"Anonymous","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Savings
    Anonymous 14th May 2026
  • 5.00/5

    Monmouthshire BS, supporting local!

    I live in Monmouthshire I only have a small savings account but I like using my local Building society

    {"display":"Dianne W","full_name":"Dianne W","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Savings
    Dianne W 12th May 2026
  • 4.00/5

    Problem with logging out of new app

    Just downloaded your app which was very straightforward until I tried to logout. It just kept going to Face ID and logging me back in... Just downloaded your app which was very straightforward until I tried to logout. It just kept going to Face ID and logging me back in on a loop when I pressed the logout button. Is this a glitch? Read more Read less

    {"display":"Maggie ","full_name":"Maggie ","avatar":{"url":"\/assets\/images\/default_new.png"}}'s avatar
    Savings
    Maggie 12th May 2026

    Products from Monmouthshire Building Society

    Showing all products offered by Monmouthshire Building Society

    We are Smart Money People

    Join 2 million active users who make better financial decisions with the power of reviews.

    Create an account

    Protecting trust by verifying companies and reviewers

    The only site that specialises in financial services

    Providing everyday people with a voice