Write a review

Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages reviews

Name: Mortgages
Rating: 4.83 (244 reviews)

View other Monmouthshire Building Society products

4.77

Based on 244 reviews, last reviewed 9th Sep 2025

20% increase in 5 star reviews

in the past 90 days

200% increase in 1 star reviews

in the past 90 days

92%

3 star

2 star

Latest highest rating:

5

Exceptional Service and Mortgage Advice Our Mortgage Adviser, Anita, was exceptional throughout. She was extremely helpful, responded in a timely manner and really went the extra mile. She i... Read more Reviewed on: 9th September 2025

Latest lowest rating:

1

The Monmouthshire Building Society have a 'floor' ra... The Monmouthshire Building Society have a 'floor' rate on their variable rate products that, at the moment, doesn't go beneath 3.5 %. However they hav... Read more Reviewed on: 24th August 2025

Visit provider site Read all reviews Write a review

About this product

Monmouthshire Building Society offer a range of mortgages to cover different borrowing needs.

Whether you’re looking to buy your first home, move somewhere bigger, or simply get a better deal, you can book an online appointment with a Monmouthshire mortgage advisor.

Monmouthshire Building Society mortgage reviews help you find out what it’s really like to be a customer. If you’ve used Monmouthshire Building Society before, you can also leave a review and share your experience.

Review Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages now

Help others make smarter decisions by sharing your own experience.

Write a review

Monmouthshire Building Society Mortgages reviews (244)

Exceptional Service and Mortgage Advice

Our Mortgage Adviser, Anita, was exceptional throughout. She was extremely helpful, responded in a timely manner and really went the extra mile. She is a credit to the Monmouthshire Building Society. We felt reassured all the way along. Furthermore, Monmouthshire have provided our mortgages for many years and we have found them to be extremely good. Reviewed on: 9th September 2025

Very helpful, very efficient and very friendly.

Very helpful, very efficient and very friendly. Leon was a pleasure to deal with. Reviewed on: 29th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society We are so happy you left the society a review we will share your comment with Leon, thank you. Response date: 2nd September 2025

The Monmouthshire Building Society have a 'floor' ra...

The Monmouthshire Building Society have a 'floor' rate on their variable rate products that, at the moment, doesn't go beneath 3.5 %. However they have no ceiling rate, so when the interest rates went up exponentially, there was nothing to protect their members. They therefore design their products to protect themselves alone. Potential customers should also know that for a long time preferential rates were offered to new members at the expense of existing members. Should a mutual building Society behave this way? Their mortgage products are all smoke and mirrors, a maze of early repayment fees, product fees, floor rates, set up so that their members will always be disadvantaged. I read the following today: "Monmouthshire Building Society has today (August 20th) published its financial results for 2024-25. The Newport-based Society has announced a 61% increase in profits for the last financial year, up from £2.3million, to £3.7million, and total assets reaching £1.72bn." Well it's no wonder. There's only ever going to be profits for the building society which plays heads I win, tails you lose. If you're looking for a fair building society which operates for the benefit of its members, don't look at the Monmouthshire. Reviewed on: 24th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society We are sorry to hear that you are unhappy with the product(s) that you have received from the Society. As an FCA regulated lender, we strive to treat all customers fairly and transparently. We offer a broad range of mortgage products directly and through our broker network and it is important that customers fully understand the features of their mortgage before proceeding, to ensure it is right for them. The setting of differing rates for new and existing customers is standard commercial practice to attract new business. If you remain dissatisfied following the outcome of a complaint, you have the right to refer your complaint to the FOS https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/ Response date: 27th August 2025

Leon was really easy to talk to and dealt with my ra...

Leon was really easy to talk to and dealt with my rate switch in a timely and efficient manner. Reviewed on: 18th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with the Society. We'll share your feedback with Leon. Response date: 19th August 2025

Mortgage with Monmouthshire Building Society

I had a mortgage with Monmouthshire Building Society which was coming to the end of its term. I spoke with one of your advisers, Leon Jenkins, with regard to finding a new mortgage product. Leon was totally professional in his advice while at the same time being helpful, courteous and polite. He answered all my questions objectively, clearly and with great patience with the result that I felt reassured that I was taking out the best product for me. He made a potentially stressful experience into a very pleasant one. Based on my experience I would be very happy to recommend Monmouthshire Building Society. Reviewed on: 18th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for leaving a review for the Society, it's great to hear your positive feedback. We'll share your review with Leon. Response date: 19th August 2025

Outstanding Mortgage Advice from Claire Oakey

I recently had an appointment with Claire Oakey, and I cannot recommend her highly enough. She was extremely polite, professional, and very patient throughout the whole process. Even though I asked lots of questions and wanted to explore different options, Claire was always accommodating and explained everything clearly. She carefully compared different products, including options with and without fees, discussed reducing the mortgage term, and thoroughly checked my income and outgoings to ensure everything was suitable. I felt completely supported and reassured by her advice. The customer service I received was outstanding — Claire’s knowledge, patience, and professionalism really stood out. Although I had competitive rates from other providers, I chose to stay with Monmouthshire because the service I received from Claire exceeded all others. Highly recommended — thank you, Claire! I’m Reviewed on: 16th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you so much for taking your time to write up such a lovely review for Claire, we'll make sure to pass on your feedback. Response date: 18th August 2025

Leon, my advisor was excellent and understood my cir...

Leon, my advisor was excellent and understood my circumstances and recommended an appropriable product accordingly Reviewed on: 14th August 2025

MBS excellent experience

From the first time I got in touch with MBS it has been a very professional excellent service. Reviewed on: 13th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society We are so happy to hear when our members have a good experience with us, thank you for leaving us a review. Response date: 13th August 2025

Monmouthshire Building Society - Mortgages Review

We have been members of the Society for 6 years, and are now seeking to move, home. Claire, our mortgage advisor has been fantastic, and very efficient. I would say that whilst you might not necessarily get the best rates when compared to other lenders, they are still competitive and provide a far more personal service, which is worth more to us than a percentage point. Overall, I would not hesitate to recommend Monmouthshire Building Society. Reviewed on: 12th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for leaving a review, we are so pleased to hear that you have had a great experience with the Society. We’ll share your feedback with Claire. Response date: 12th August 2025

Excellent mortgage advice.

Leon has been brilliant from the start - called me when he said he would, responded to emails, sent me the information required, and explained everything with detail & confidence; making an often difficult and stressful process as stress-free as possible. He has responded to my many questions, providing the clarity I needed, and has explained next steps and what’s required of me. Ownership, clear next steps, and timescales, are very important to me in customer service - all of which were provided in a friendly and professional manner! Thank you very much! Reviewed on: 8th August 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society That is amazing to hear. We are so glad you had a good experience with us. We will make sure Leon sees your review. Thank you. Response date: 8th August 2025

Do you have a different Monmouthshire Building Society product?

Share your experiences with products to help others make smarter financial decisions and learn more about different products available. Write a review

Alternative products

Mortgages
from Mansfield Building Society 4.64 from 359 reviews
Mortgages
from Scottish Building Society 4.67 from 367 reviews
Mortgages
from Hinckley & Rugby Building Society 4.55 from 377 reviews

Want to see more from Monmouthshire Building Society?

Savings
from Monmouthshire Building Society 4.89 from 2525 reviews

View all products

Join Smart Money People

Keep up to date on ratings of your favourite businesses. Find out about our awards and write new reviews with ease

Create an account

News, guides and insight from our team

View resource hub