Smart Money People Logo
Share this page
Link copied

Footman James: Classic Car Insurance Broker reviews

View other Footman James products
4.89
Based on 591 reviews, last reviewed 11th Apr 2025
100% decrease in 5 star reviews
in the past 90 days
No new 1 star reviews
in the past 90 days
See only 5 star reviews
92%
See only 4 star reviews
7%
See only 3 star reviews
0%
See only 2 star reviews
0%
See only 1 star reviews
1%

Latest highest rating:

5

very good I recommend with confidence very good I recommend with confidence Reviewed on: 11th April 2025
Doina A's avatar
Doina A

Latest lowest rating:

1

Check your policy I had a classic loved BMW E30.I believed that Footman James were my insurer, they were not. Although their glossy website looks great, READ THE SMALL ... Read more Reviewed on: 1st June 2022
Lorraine Vickery's avatar
Lorraine Vickery
Read all reviews Write a review

About this product

Looking to read or write Footman James classic car insurance broker reviews? Smart Money People is the best place online for independent financial services reviews. Our community writes Footman James classic car insurance broker reviews to help you decide when choosing financial products, so if you're already a Footman James client, join in and share a review of your own!

Review Footman James: Classic Car Insurance Broker now

Help others make smarter decisions by sharing your own experience.
Give a 1 star rating Give a 2 star rating Give a 3 star rating Give a 4 star rating Give a 5 star rating
Write a review

Footman James Classic Car Insurance Broker reviews (591)

very good I recommend with confidence

5
very good I recommend with confidence Reviewed on: 11th April 2025
Doina A's avatar
Doina A

Classic car insurance

5
Easy to sort what I needed, friendly knowledgeable staff on the phone, and a competitive renewal price Reviewed on: 22nd September 2023
Peter Winfield's avatar
Peter Winfield

Check your policy

1
I had a classic loved BMW E30.I believed that Footman James were my insurer, they were not. Although their glossy website looks great, READ THE SMALL PRINT. There was an accident where my E30 was deemed a total loss. Then all became clear, I had been passed to Ageas. Ageas are not classic car insurers they will not insure a classic car unless it is passed to them by a BROKER. I now know that Footman James acted as a broker not an insurer ,I was oblivious to this. I specifically wanted an insurer that appreciated a classic car owners needs, they are so unlike modern vehicles. I believed that Footman James could provide this. They did not. Ageas have made my life an absolute nightmare and I would not wish this on anyone else. I have been through hell. Check your policy you could be with Ageas or similar. Just be very careful, you could lose your precious vehicle and your mind. Reviewed on: 1st June 2022
Lorraine Vickery's avatar
Lorraine Vickery

Great Broker

5
Competitive and Great Staff with good knowledge Reviewed on: 16th September 2021
Gary Hughes 's avatar
Gary Hughes

Outrageous attempt to rip me off

1
Utter rip off. A failed attempt to rip me off after 8 years by trying to charge me over 51% (£182.71) more for classic car insurance than that provided by another well known and renowned classic car insurance provider. I have been with Footman James for over 8 years for classic car insurance. Unfortunately, they decided to use that longevity in order to try and rip me off with the upmost contempt. I can only assume that those 8 years loyalty suggested to Footman James that I am either stupid or gullible or too lazy to shop around. Probably all three. I received a classic car renewal quote of these people showing a marked increase in my premium that I believed could not be justified. A premium quoted at £436.91. Upon questioning their price they stated that if I came back to them with a cheaper quote off another supplier they would look at their pricing. I came back to them with a quote at £100.91 cheaper for increased insurance provisions. I also informed them, as I had the other provider, that I had had a modern car wrote off by a lorry in December 2019 as a no fault and settled claim. A no fault settled claim as my car had been parked in a car park, empty with no one in it when a lorry decided to drive over it. That declaration was like a green light for them to really treat me like a fool. Upon this notice they decided to stick on a further £98.80, increasing the quote from £436.91 to £535.71. They even threw at me the added insult of claiming this further £98.80 increase included a 10% discount. On my challenge this was all justified by way of claiming the increase was computer driven and there was nothing they could do to reduce it. To that end I have dropped Footman James with the same contempt they have shown towards me. I have now insured with another renowned classic car insurer with better provisions at just £353. This includes full breakdown, home start, recovery, tax and arrangement fee, etc. To spell this out in no uncertain terms, Footman James wanted £182.71 more for providing less cover than that which I now have with another well known provider. In percentage terms that is approximately 51.25% more for less cover. This was nothing less than an outrageous attempt to rip off even though I had been with them for over 8 years. I hope as many people as possible read this review in its entirety. Reviewed on: 25th February 2020
T Johnson's avatar
T Johnson

Simply the Best

5
I have or have had all (10 at present) classic and modern motorcycles covered by FJ for many years. They offer great value are very knowledgeable and you can always speak to a human being. I have learned to my cost recently hoe frustrating your portal! or live chat! can be. John Knibb Reviewed on: 4th September 2019
John Knibb's avatar
John Knibb

Over £400 stolen from us

1
My husband and I are having awful problems with Footman James! My husband rang to inform them that his bike was no longer being held in a garage, and they said they wouldn’t insure it and that he’d have to cancel his policy. He was then told that they couldn’t cancel his policy until his third instalment of £225.68 which was due to come out the following week had been paid, and that his bike would no longer be insured. I found this exceedingly odd but agreed and when the third instalment was due, he paid it. I knew he was due a refund as he had paid three instalments (one of £225.69, and two of £225.68) which makes up for 9 months of the year, and he’d only had the policy since 11/01/19 and he’d called at the first week of March! But he received a call today to say he would only be getting a refund of £218. So extremely unfair! I am very unhappy that he has been first made to make a payment when they told him he needed to cancel, and then have the audacity to only give him a refund of £218. Absolutely disgraceful. They pretty much put the gun to his head and stole the money from him. I’d warn everyone to stay away. Seriously, it’s not worth the time or money. Reviewed on: 15th March 2019
Megan Dalton's avatar
Megan Dalton

Great service

5
When I bought my classic car I looked at numerous Insures but came up with Footman James great personal advice and service. Thanks to very one Reviewed on: 6th February 2019
Mr Alan Housley's avatar
Mr Alan Housley

Footman James are Wonderful

5
Footman James offer a friendly, personal service adaptable to you and your needs. Their insurance service is clear and affordable, while offering high quality cover for you and your vehicle's. Reviewed on: 16th January 2019
Jen's avatar
Jen

friendly and helpful

5
A very personal experience making insuring my vehicle simple and hassle free. Reviewed on: 12th October 2018
whiteeedotcom's avatar
whiteeedotcom

Review Footman James: Classic Car Insurance Broker now

Help others make smarter decisions by sharing your own experience.
Give a 1 star rating Give a 2 star rating Give a 3 star rating Give a 4 star rating Give a 5 star rating
Write a review
Are you a business? Get insights, reply to reviews, invite customers and understand their needs

Join Smart Money People

Keep up to date on ratings of your favourite businesses. Find out about our awards and write new reviews with ease

Create an account
Man on beach

News, guides and insight from our team

View resource hub
UK money news stories - 24 July 2024
UK money news stories - 24 July 2024
24th July 2024
Posted in Money Talks by Errolyn Smith
Your Money, Your Voice: Have your say
Your Money, Your Voice: Have your say
24th July 2024
Posted in Our insights by Errolyn Smith
Our latest research - customers see little impact of FCA's Consumer Duty one year on
Our latest research - customers see little impact of FCA's Consumer Duty one year on
24th July 2024
Posted in Our insights by Darryl Barkwill
Consumer credit awards winners 2024
Consumer credit awards winners 2024
11th July 2024
Posted in Awards by Darryl Barkwill