Write a review

Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages reviews

Name: Mortgages
Rating: 4.84 (231 reviews)

View other Monmouthshire Building Society products

4.79

Based on 231 reviews, last reviewed 14th Jul 2025

41% decrease in 5 star reviews

in the past 90 days

100% increase in 1 star reviews

in the past 90 days

91%

3 star

2 star

Latest highest rating:

5

Claire was very professional. Claire was very professional. She explained everything in an easy to understand way, Claire went through the options available to me in a way that it ... Read more Reviewed on: 10th July 2025

Latest lowest rating:

1

Lack of communication I requested a decision in principle to take a mortgage out, and after having replied with my availability, I did not hear from the mortgage coordinato... Read more Reviewed on: 14th July 2025

Visit provider site Read all reviews Write a review

About this product

Monmouthshire Building Society mortgage reviews can help you to find out what other Smart Money People have to say about what could be your biggest ever financial purchase. Smart Money People was established in 2014 to help provide an independent source of Monmouthshire Building Society mortgage reviews. You write your mortgage reviews here to help other people find the best mortgage providers. Together, we can make financial services work better for everyone.

Review Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages now

Help others make smarter decisions by sharing your own experience.

Write a review

Monmouthshire Building Society Mortgages reviews (231)

MBS Rate Switch

Mortgage advisor Olly proactively called me to query a VM that I had left, a few days prior. He was professional, engaging and arranged my rate switch efficiently and effectively. The MBS website is terrible but thankfully they have professionals like Olly & Adam that more than make up for it. Reviewed on: 14th January 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for the Society, your feedback will be shared with Olly and Adam. We are sorry to hear that you didn't have a good experience whilst visiting our website. Response date: 15th January 2025

Our two year mortgage product was coming to an end.

Our two year mortgage product was coming to an end. After speaking with Adam he sent across via email some options of mortgage products and made an appointment for Jamie to call me a few days later to discuss which product we were interested in. I can not fault their friendliness or competence in dealing with me. Moving forward we have another 2 year mortgage deal which we are happy with. Reviewed on: 9th January 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for leaving a review for the Direct Sales team. We are so pleased that you had a good experience with the Society. Your comments will be shared with Jamie and Adam. Response date: 9th January 2025

The Truth about the Monmouthshire Building Society

Once upon a time building societies existed to help people in their communities. In the case of the Monmouthshire Building Society this is no longer the case. We have suffered extraordinarily difficult circumstances and they have and still are declining to offer us any meaningful help. Do not trust them. Do not believe their advertisements 'We are a mutual building society run for the benefit of our members'. This could not be further from the truth. Despite many requests they will not even meet us in person, which is a strange way to 'benefit' us. They are not reducing their interest rates as the Bank of England have done because in their words “As a Building Society we can increase or decrease our SVR at any time, and we do not need to follow the movement in the Bank of England Base Rate. This basically means that they can and are quite prepared to ruin their members. They have behaved so badly towards us that it beggars belief. Their complaints procedure is utterly pointless. Despite stating that they agreed with one of our complaints, they still were 'unable to uphold' it for an utterly nonsensical reason which has no correlation to the complaint. The complaints procedure is a box ticking exercise designed solely for them to appear to be fulfilling their obligations. Above all else, remember that the Monmouthshire Building Society are money lenders who, just like all other money lenders, are in it for themselves and themselves alone. They are causing us catastrophic financial ruin which was completely avoidable and the bottom line is they do not care. Even if you are critically vulnerable, they do not care. They should be utterly ashamed of themselves. Reviewed on: 6th January 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society We are sorry to hear that you are unhappy with the service or support that you have received from the Society, as we strive to do all that we reasonably can to support members facing financial difficulties or uncertainty. If you remain dissatisfied following the outcome of a complaint, you have the right to refer your complaint to the FOS https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/. Response date: 8th January 2025

Hassle free telephone support

Had several telephone conversations with Joshua Davies regarding possible mortgage Rate Switch options. He clearly explained the alternatives and was very helpful and understanding about our circumstances. Consequently, we completed a swap promptly and with very little effort or hassle on our part. Reviewed on: 5th January 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for taking the time to leave a review following your rate switch. We are so pleased that you had a good experience, your comments will be shared with Joshua. Response date: 6th January 2025

In branch service review

Friendly and helpful staff at the Caldicot branch. Reviewed on: 4th January 2025

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for the Society. Your comments will be passed on to the Caldicot branch. Response date: 19th February 2025

Excellent service, good rates and very pleased

Excellent service, good rates and very pleased Reviewed on: 27th December 2024

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for the Society, we are so pleased that you had an excellent experience. Your comments will be shared with the Direct Sales team. Response date: 27th December 2024

Helpful kind understanding professional efficient

Helpful kind understanding professional efficient Reviewed on: 20th December 2024

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for the mortgage team. Response date: 20th December 2024

Mortgage Product Review

Michelle was thorough and diligent in reviewing my personal financial situation. We then discussed my goals and which products would best meet those objectives. At every stage Michelle was very clear on the new product and its features and always checked I was comfortable proceeding. She was patient, professional and at all times clear. Her advice and support gave me peace of mind Reviewed on: 12th December 2024

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for taking the time to leave a review following your mortgage appointment. We are so pleased that you had a good experience. Your review will be shared with Michelle. Response date: 16th December 2024

Mortgage advice appointment with Leon

Mortgage advice appointment with Leon - Leon was extremely well prepared for our meeting, having confirmed prior what would be required. He was thorough and obviously knowledgeable. He checked in prior to our appointment time to ensure the time was still suitable and followed up with an email after the appointment thanking me for my time. So far the remortgage experience with the Society has been excellent Reviewed on: 6th December 2024

Reply from Monmouthshire Building Society Thank you for leaving a review, we are so pleased to hear that you have had a great experience with the Society. Your comments will be passed on to Leon. Response date: 6th December 2024

Anita was great, friendly and informative

Anita was great, friendly and informative Reviewed on: 28th November 2024

Review Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages now

Help others make smarter decisions by sharing your own experience.

Write a review

Alternative products

Mortgages
from Aldermore 3.30 from 7 reviews
Tracker Rate Mortgage
from HSBC 3.73 from 15 reviews
Mortgages
from Capital Credit Union 5.00 from 37 reviews

Join Smart Money People

Keep up to date on ratings of your favourite businesses. Find out about our awards and write new reviews with ease

Create an account

News, guides and insight from our team

View resource hub

Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages reviews

41% decrease in 5 star reviews

100% increase in 1 star reviews

Latest highest rating:

5

Latest lowest rating:

1

About this product

Review Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages now

Monmouthshire Building Society Mortgages reviews (231)

MBS Rate Switch

Our two year mortgage product was coming to an end.

The Truth about the Monmouthshire Building Society

Hassle free telephone support

In branch service review

Excellent service, good rates and very pleased

Helpful kind understanding professional efficient

Mortgage Product Review

Mortgage advice appointment with Leon

Anita was great, friendly and informative

Review Monmouthshire Building Society: Mortgages now

Join Smart Money People

News, guides and insight from our team

UK money news stories - 24 July 2024

Your Money, Your Voice: Have your say

Our latest research - customers see little impact of FCA's Consumer Duty one year on

Consumer credit awards winners 2024